
Prologue
Pacey slumped in his seat; gazing out blankly at the passing scenery, the familiar streets and shops and houses they passed really only shadowy blurs in his periphery. Yet still he envisioned them clearly, each landmark engrained in his minds eye to the point he didnt actually have to look to see.
Hed lived in this town since the day he was born. It had been the backdrop of his every memory, the entire landscape of his life. And, for a while this year, it had all seemed somehow bigger, brighter, more like a place youd call home. Its funny how ones whole outlook can change, views can be altered, simply by feeling a little less alone.
But now here he was.
Alone again.
And this was just Capeside again.
He glanced over uncertainly at his father, discreetly studying him for a brief moment. The hard, humorless line of his jaw, one large hand gripping the top of the steering wheel as he drove, his unreadable eyes fixed steadily on the road stretched out before them.
Pacey had composed himself enough by now to begin feeling slightly foolish about his earlier breakdown, and couldnt help but wonder what his father was thinking. What he was thinking about him, to be more exact. Had he secretly disappointed him, or had he only fulfilled his fathers lowest expectations yet again? Pacey wasnt sure, and he couldnt tell by looking at him. Because the sad reality was that he didnt know him that well.
There were only a handful of times in Paceys life that this man beside him had even acted like a father. Today had been one of them.
But today was almost over.
It seemed strange to think how quickly things could change, how only a few short days ago his girlfriend had been his entire life to the point he didnt even really care about his issues with his father anymore. Didnt really need him, or anyone else for that matter, because he had her. Yet now she was gone, and it would seem his father was the only one he had to turn to. Pacey had to admit that, in some weird way, he felt kind of like a wounded soldier behind enemy lines.
Perhaps part of the reason Pacey was feeling so unsure and uncomfortable was that he knew it couldnt last. That his father had possibly only been motivated by pity, and it would eventually pass. Pity for his eternally screwed-up son who couldnt do anything right.
Not even love someone.
Pacey turned his gaze forward again, miserably lowering his eyes to the dashboard. Hed tried his best to save her, to play the hero, to be what she needed him to be, and, in the end, hed failed.
He hadnt been enough.
The car swayed slightly as his father turned into their driveway and hit that dip in the paved surface near the road, and then they were slowing to a stop by the house.
Pacey opened his door immediately, but hesitated before he actually got out of his seat when his eyes fell on a lone figure sitting on their front steps, shrouded slightly in the veil of night.
Realizing who it was, he ducked his head and reached up to quickly swipe at his eyes in embarrassment, knowing that they were still damp and probably red-rimmed, and swallowed back the lump in his throat so it landed with a dull thud at the bottom of his hollow stomach.
He closed the door, walking stiffly and hesitantly around the front of the car with a mild frown of concern.
Joey?
She bowed her head as she pushed herself up from the steps to stand, hiding her own eyes behind her thick strands of long hair, but not before he saw the dark orbs were shadowed in grief.
His heart lurched unexpectedly, almost surprising him to realize it was still there beating inside his chest.
Are you okay?
He stopped in front of her, having to restrain his immediate instinct to reach out to offer some form of physical comfort, knowing Joey Potter well enough to ascertain the perimeters of her invisible boundaries, the height of her walls, the thickness of her armor.
John Witter had gotten out of the car by this point and was approaching them as she glanced up, her liquid eyes briefly sliding over Pacey before she turned away.
Yeah, I, um...I was actually here to talk to your father.
She held her head up a little higher as she said this, tilting her chin upwards as well, a look of false bravado Pacey recognized all too well. One that hed watched her perfect over all the years hed known her and seen her life crumble around her.
Hello, Joey.
His father moved to stand next to him, his voice calm, careful. And almost sounding as if hed expected her to be here.
Pacey barely glanced at him before returning his steady gaze to her.
Oh, well...okay. He stammered a bit. I, ah...do you want me to leave you two alone then?
He shifted uncertainly and studied Joey as he said this, realizing for some reason he was actually hoping that she would ask him to stay. Maybe even needing her to ask him to stay. Needing to feel like someone, somewhere, could use his support, in any small or inconsequential way, if only to make him feel like he was still here...still part of something. Something to take him away from this low point where he couldnt imagine feeling any more isolated. Any more alone.
Pacey, I think it might be better if you let us just talk a minute, okay?
His father directed the comment to him, using that same steady, soothing tone, but kept his eyes on Joey.
Pacey only nodded his head in compliance as he moved to step past her with a soft sigh of resignation, heading into the house, but suddenly he felt her hand reach out to grasp onto his arm.
Pacey, wait...
Her eyes glinted like black embers as she glanced up to meet his gaze, and in that instant he experienced the whole scene at the Icehouse as if it were happening again right in front of him, the heat of the flickering flames, the flash of terror in her face, her body trembling uncontrollably in his arms as he dragged her out. The way he felt when he realized he was far more afraid for her than he was for himself.
The feeling, the image, left him as she abruptly pulled her eyes away to look back to his father.
If thats okay, I mean...Id like him to stay. She shrugged with a smirk, a slight scoffing noise that didnt sound much like a laugh. Its not like I have anything to hide from him, from anyone...not now.
John Witter only nodded his head slowly, motioning with one hand towards the front door.
Well, why dont we step inside then? We can talk in the den.
Pacey glanced around in mild embarrassment as he stepped into the house behind her, remembering there was a reason he never brought any friends home, but it quickly passed as he realized Joey probably had much bigger things on her mind, and that she wasnt the type to judge anyone by their standard of living anyway.
His father motioned them into the den as his mother appeared in the kitchen doorway, and Pacey could detect the faint scent of something unidentifiable following after her from the oven. Unfortunately, he had to acknowledge that it would probably be equally as unidentifiable when it reached his plate.
Finally! Ive been holding dinner...its still warm... She called out, lowing to a stop with a rather vacant smile when she saw Joey. Oh, hello, um...
She struggled a bit as if it were on the tip of her tongue until Joey spoke up softly.
Its Joey. How are you, Mrs. Witter?
Right, Joanie. The Potter girl. She nodded her head in acknowledgement as her smile tightened. How are you, dear?
Its Jo-ey, Mom. Pacey wearily corrected her through gritted teeth.
Were just going to be few minutes here. John Witter spoke up, resting his hand on Joeys shoulder to guide her towards the den.
Oh, okay.
Pacey noticed his mother hesitate before she turned away, watching them all move into the next room. Even when the rest of Capeside might have been unaware, it had never been a secret around his house that the Potters had a criminal connection through their father. And, though no one had ever come out and exactly said the words, he knew his friendship with Joey had perhaps been a source of some mild discomfort for his parents over the years, given his father was Sheriff around these parts and all.
Whenever they were paying enough attention to Paceys life to actually realize who his friends even were, that is.
Joey was moving to sit, rubbing her hands nervously over the legs of her jeans as Pacey eased himself onto the couch cushion next to her, their attention focused on his father as he pulled his worn and battered recliner chair a little closer, sitting forward to rest his elbows on his knees. When he finally spoke, it was in a gentle tone that Pacey nearly didnt recognize.
Now, what did you want to talk about?
The corner of her mouth tugged up sadly. I think you know why Im here.
John Witter only dropped his gaze to the floor with an almost equally sad smile of acknowledgement.
Well, then... He cleared his throat as he returned his gaze to her face. Do you have any questions for me?
Paceys eyes drifted back and forth between them, surprised at the tact and sympathy his father was displaying, when it had seemed so certain only days ago that he somehow had it in for the Potter family and held no respect or understanding for all they had been through.
It was definitely a day for seeing his father in a new light. Whether he remained in this light or went back to the dark side, Pacey supposed only time would tell.
I, um...actually I do. Joey responded hesitantly. Id like to know what it is you know...about my father and about whatever it is he may be involved in.
John Witter seemed to consider this a long while, reaching up to rub absently at his chin as if he were figuring out the best way to approach the subject, but then Joey spoke up again, sounding slightly more defeated than before.
The fire was his fault, wasnt it?
He began his response carefully, but with deliberate seriousness as he held her gaze.
It has recently come to our attention that your father may have made some people very angry, Joey...and these are not nice people. Its a common problem youll find at almost any major commercial harbor along the East Coast...the drug trade. As much as wed like to eradicate it and as hard as we try to fight it...its there and it exists. These people run multi-million dollar businesses, and they give a whole new meaning to the term cutthroat practices. Your father... He hesitated as he amended his words. We believe your father may have gotten involved in dealing drugs within an already established territory. And weve determined that the fire at your familys restaurant was arson, and we believe it was intended to be a warning of sorts.
Pacey watched Joey out of the corner of his eye as she cast her gaze to the floor to nod her head slowly, her bottom lip only trembling once as she absorbed this, and he wondered again why it is some people never seem to get a break. Why bad things always have to happen to them. Why bad things had to happen to her. Hadnt she been through enough?
Without even realizing what he was doing, he lifted his hand to her shoulder, resting it there gently.
But she stiffened almost immediately against his touch, nearly shrugging it off as she raised her eyes back to his father to respond with a near deadly quiet.
And they wont stop there, will they? I mean, were...my family is in trouble right now, arent they? Bessie, Alexander...me...hes put us all in danger, hasnt he?
John Witter regarded her a long moment before he nodded his head. Yes. We have reason to believe you are in some danger...as long as your father continues to engage in these illegal activities.
Pacey retracted his hand awkwardly as he cleared his throat to interject with a shrug of his shoulder.
Maybe now, that this has happened...maybe now hell be forced to come clean. Or be forced to stop.
John Witter shook his head without missing a beat. Its not that simple. Once youre involved with these kinds of people...getting out is very difficult. The men we believe he may be doing business with are no better than the ones we believe may be responsible for the arson. There is no quick and easy solution if this is left up to him, and every day...every hour...that goes by after this will only pull you all deeper into the problems he has created. He paused meaningfully. Theyve already made it personal, you see. More than likely, the threats will increase considerably, to your father...to your whole family.
He seemed to let these words sink it, marinate and resonate with her a while before he continued.
And I have already given your father the opportunity to come clean, to admit his involvement...
And he didnt. Joey finished for him, lowering her eyes to the floor once again.
No. John Witter confirmed with a grimace. He didnt. But, in a situation such as this, he may feel like he can handle it, or that he just needs more time to figure a way out...but I can assure you that his time has already run out. It only gets worse for him from all sides now.
So, what is it I can do? She lifted her eyes, which were brimming with tears even though she held her voice as steady as possible. To get this to stop?
We need to have something more solid, more concrete, than the circumstantial evidence and informant tips we have received to date. He narrowed his eyes. In more frank terms, we need to have something on your father that will allow us to take him into custody and make these charges stick, to put an immediate end to this. However, if he was using the restaurant as a front for drug dealing, any evidence of that has probably gone up in smoke.
After the fire, I, ah...I went home and checked all over the house...went through his things... Joey offered quietly as Pacey glanced over at her in mild surprise. I couldnt find anything there.
John Witter shrugged. All it would really take would be his confession.
And you need that on record, right? She let out a shaky breath.
Pacey turned his eyes on his father, who only nodded his head in response.
He would tell me the truth if I asked. Joey quickly reached up to wipe a tear that spilled out onto her cheek away. I could wear a wire.
Whoa, whoa...wait a minute, Joey. Pacey spoke up, almost chuckling although there was no humor in his words. Lets not get crazy here...
Son... His father sighed heavily as he shot him warning look.
You cant be serious. Paceys voice nearly cracked as it rose in disbelief as he stared at his father, and he began to gesture with his hands. She cant do that...and you cant ask her to do something like that, Pop.
Pacey... Joey tilted her head towards him without actually making eye contact, the exasperation and annoyance in her weary voice letting him know that this was exactly what she intended to do.
Let me do it. Pacey suddenly burst out, swallowing nervously, desperate to do something to stop this, realizing that, in this situation, there was actually something he could do to help. Ill wear it.
John Witter only sighed in response, lowering his eyes to the floor.
Joey shook her head. Hes not going to tell you, Pacey.
But you said he pretty much admitted it to Dawson. Pacey persisted. Ill simply drop a few hints that Dawson put me in the know, and...and... His voice softened but held its urgency. Let me do this. I can do this.
Its not about that, Pacey. She turned to hold his gaze, the vulnerability in her face overshadowed by determination. This is something I have to do.
He lost himself for a moment in her gaze, the emotions he saw in the depths of her eyes seeming to be at war, the type of battles he thought only his own fought.
But, thank you. She offered quietly, just the slightest corner of her mouth tilting up.
Pacey only nodded his head in acknowledgement as his shoulders slumped, watching as she turned back to his father.
So, how is this going to work?
Joey sat on the edge of the dock, staring down into the murky, brackish water, her bare legs dangling over the side as she absently rubbed the heel of her foot against the rough, splintered surface of the wooden piling until it was nearly red and raw. But she almost welcomed the sharp sensations of pain she was creating, something to take her mind off the dull, gnawing ache in the pit of her stomach.
She closed her eyes to the blurry onslaught of stinging tears, clutching the material of her tank top in her fist to pull it away from her body as she felt one of those waves of nausea strike again. She was almost certain she was going to be sick, and had been sitting out here, gulping in the fresh air, her head bowed over the creek for what seemed like hours.
Bessie was in the house, dinnertime had already come and gone, and she was probably getting Alexander ready for bed at this point, since the sky was now streaked with the colors of the setting sun beyond the tops of the trees, the mirror image of illumination reflected in the currents of water below. But she hadnt once to come out to check on Joey. Not that Joey could blame her.
Because she understood it must be hard to figure out what to say to someone whod just deceived and betrayed your father and handed him over to be carted off to prison.
Of course, the argument was there that it had all been her fathers own fault. He was the one who was supposed to be the adult. He was the one they were supposed to trust, supposed to be able to count on. He was the one who had deceived and betrayed them first, and Joey had seen no other way out to save her family. Maybe someday Bessie would understand that. Believe that.
And maybe someday Joey would, too.
Suddenly she realized someone was there, approaching, the ancient planks of the dock creaking under footsteps. She didnt even have the strength to compose herself, for one brief moment struggling with both hope and dread that it was Dawson.
She heard a soft exhalation of breath, a quiet sigh carried on the breeze, and barely glanced over to see it was actually Pacey lowering himself down to sit next to her, although he maintained a certain distance.
Wavering between disappointment and relief, she only continued to stare into the water, having nothing to say to him...nothing to say anyone. Wishing hed just get up and leave as much as a part of her was really tired of being all alone out here.
Hey.
His voice sounded unfamiliar, quiet and dull, lacking that teasing lilt of sarcasm he always seemed to use with her.
She swallowed, trying to see if she could perhaps form a response, but then gave up in defeat, still only staring at her shadowy reflection in the water.
He sat there a moment before he broke the silence again.
Im sorry that this all had to happen...like this.
Why? Its not your fault, she murmured with her own weak attempt at sarcasm, realizing her voice sounded strange to her own ears, as it was the first time shed spoken in several hours.
Have you talked to Dawson? She tilted her head towards him.
Um, yeah...in passing. Pacey shrugged noncommittally. He was, um...he was pretty upset. He glanced over as he narrowed his eyes in concern. And hes worried about you...you know?
Joey shifted positions as she shook her head dismissively. Well, if he sent you here to check up on me, or to see if Ive changed my mind, you can just tell him that...
Dawson didnt send me. Pacey cut in quietly. I just wanted to see if you were okay.
Joey felt the well of tears building and needed to bite down hard on her lower lip to keep it from trembling, refusing to give in, his gentle words somehow sneaking past her safety barriers.
Well, Im fine. She practically spat out through gritted teeth, using every ounce of self-control to maintain some composure, when all she really wanted to do was fling her arms around his neck and bury her face in his chest and cry until she had nothing left inside her.
But she couldnt do that.
Im just a little mad at the world right now. She glanced over at him sharply. And Id just really like to be left alone.
Pacey only nodded his head, but she noticed his body slump dejectedly before he pushed himself up to stand on the dock.
Okay. He shrugged before he shoved his hands into his jean pockets, glancing out towards the creek as his voice lowered. But, from someone whos been there? Being alone isnt going to make you any less angry, or make the pain any less acute. Its just going to make you feel more alone.
With that, he turned to walk away, eventually disappearing into the shadows of the darkened yard.
Joey lifted her dark eyes, weighted with water, to watch him trudge off, his shoulders hunched with his own burdens, and she immediately felt a wave of regret to the point she almost called after him. But she didnt.
As much as Pacey Witter was probably the last person shed want to see when she was feeling like this, she realized that right about now he was probably hurting in many of the same ways she was hurting. Hed had a tough time of it with Andie this past year, but Joey had watched him reach inside himself for all those things he kept under the surface and rise to the challenge. She knew what that felt like, to go against every natural survival instinct and open up to someone enough to put your heart out there on that proverbial line. She wondered if Andie appreciated how difficult that must have been for Pacey, how much he changed himself.
She wondered if Dawson had ever appreciated that about her.
She turned to gaze back out over the creek, almost mildly amused to realize for the first time how much she and Pacey probably had in common on the inside, beneath their tough exteriors and faades. She supposed there was a good reason why theyd been able to so easily push each others buttons all these years.
And why theyd both gravitated towards someone like Dawson.
She felt another wave of nausea, her eyes brimming with tears again as her mind was dragged back to the events of that afternoon...her fathers face...Dawsons face. She had been angry at the world, how unfair it all was, and the sad thing was that shed let her world narrow down to the point it revolved around Dawson. He was the only one she could lash out at, and he received the brunt of her anger.
So, was she really angry with him? She didnt know anymore. Maybe she was angry because she felt hed taken away her choice in the matter, and it was of such a personal nature that she viewed it as some kind of violation on his part. But she was the one who had given him that kind of all-encompassing access into her life, to the point where Dawson maybe felt he could think for her. That he knew her so well, to the point where he felt he could decide what was best for her.
Maybe what she was actually angry about was that sometimes she felt like Dawson didnt really know her at all. Not that inside part of her she kept hidden away. Because, while Pacey may have opened himself up completely to Andie, Joey had to admit she didnt always do the same with Dawson. And maybe she felt angry that hed made those kinds of assumptions. Maybe she wanted to let him know that he was wrong, that he didnt really know her at all. That the fact you may spend every waking hour of every day in someones presence doesnt necessarily mean you know every thought and desire that goes through his or her mind.
All she really knew was that shed walked out of her house today to see him standing there, and it was as if she was looking at a complete stranger. Someone she didnt even want to let into her life. And, shed meant those harsh words at the moment shed said them.
Maybe shed actually just given Dawson his first real glimpse at the inside of Joey Potter. It was kind of ironic to consider one reason shed never wanted to do that was because she was afraid to lose him, to end up alone.
Right back where she started.







